Where are we located?

We're located in a cozy mini-barn in northern Shelby County, Indiana. Only about 2.5 miles south of Morristown. 4432 E 750 N, Shelbyville, IN 46176 You can find us on Google and Apple Maps.

Do we have specific in-person shopping hours?

Not really. lol We encourage everyone to message us a head of your requested visit for an appointment. We will have special holiday shopping hours though. And more info on that is located in our "Events" section.

Can I return/exchange a product?

Due to the nature of the majority of our items being personalized and custom pieces, no, we do not offer returns or exchanges. However, if we truly made an error on our part, we will do what is necessary to make that right.

Do you guys make those LARGE nursery name signs?

We do offer our version of those actually. We offer free local pick-up for those types of large items. We do not offer shipping on this time though.

Can I return or get a refund on my product

No. Due to the majority of our products being handcrafted and made specially for you, we do not offer refunds, returns, or exchanges. All sales are final. HOWEVER, if we truly made an error on our part, we will strive to correct the situation. We do all that we can to ensure you love your item(s) upon delivery and pick-up.

What payment methods do you accept?

We accept credit cards, PayPal, Apple Pay, Google Pay, card reader, tap to pay, and, of course Cash when visiting us in-person.

Discover Unique Personalized Gifts at Apple Butter Designs

top of page

we love custom orders reach out to us today

APPLE BUTTER DESIGNS

WHERE MEMORIES BECOME KEEPSAKES

Looking for something:

Browse Our Store In-Person Apple Butter Designs in Shelbyville, Indiana offers a cozy in-person shopping experience.	Shop our Milkhouse Candle Co goodies Apple Butter Designs exclusively offers Milkhouse Candle Co wax melts, car freshies, and candles in a variety of amazing scents sure to make your home smell cozy, warm, and inviting.	Large Custom Nursery Name Sign We offer local to Shelby County Indiana custom nursery name cut-outs ranging in sizes. Contact us today to order yours! melissa@applebutterdesigns.com
Personalized Sport Jersey Apple Butter Designs offers personalizable Sports Jerseys ornaments in keychains in our online and in-person ordering experiences.	Personalized Nursery Name Signs We love to make custom signs! Just like this nursery name sign that is 2-layers and ready for your personal paint selections! Email Melissa ( melissa@applebutterdesigns.com ) to order yours today!	Loved Forever Forever Loved wood sign with custom handlettered names.
Wedding and Home Decor Collect your wedding guests signatures on one of our wedding guest book alternative signs! Available in a variety of stains and sizes. To order send us an email: Melissa@applebutterdesign.com	Hand-lettered Name Cut-out Tags Apple Butter Designs offers unique personalized gifts, like, our signature hand-lettering style by our owner, Melissa, in various keepsakes	Home Sweet Home A favorite classic hymn can bring back so many memories. Let Melissa help curate in her personal hand-letting style a keepsake for your home in a timeless way.
Simply Blessed A favorite classic hymn can bring back so many memories. Let Melissa help curate in her personal hand-letting style a keepsake for your home in a timeless way.	Blessed Assurance A favorite classic hymn can bring back so many memories. Let Melissa help curate in her personal hand-letting style a keepsake for your home in a timeless way.

Shop by Category

Apparel & More

VIEW ALL

For the Office

VIEW ALL

Senior Year

VIEW ALL

Hymal Art

VIEW ALL

School Spirit

VIEW ALL

Custom Wood Signs

VIEW ALL

Home Fragrances

Wedding

VIEW ALL

Shop ALL Our Products

bottom of page

Browse Our Store In-Person

Apple Butter Designs in Shelbyville, Indiana offers a cozy in-person shopping experience.

Shop our Milkhouse Candle Co goodies

Apple Butter Designs exclusively offers Milkhouse Candle Co wax melts, car freshies, and candles in a variety of amazing scents sure to make your home smell cozy, warm, and inviting.

Large Custom Nursery Name Sign

We offer local to Shelby County Indiana custom nursery name cut-outs ranging in sizes. Contact us today to order yours! melissa@applebutterdesigns.com

Personalized Sport Jersey

Apple Butter Designs offers personalizable Sports Jerseys ornaments in keychains in our online and in-person ordering experiences.

Personalized Nursery Name Signs

We love to make custom signs! Just like this nursery name sign that is 2-layers and ready for your personal paint selections! Email Melissa ( melissa@applebutterdesigns.com ) to order yours today!

Loved Forever

Forever Loved wood sign with custom handlettered names.

Wedding and Home Decor

Collect your wedding guests signatures on one of our wedding guest book alternative signs! Available in a variety of stains and sizes. To order send us an email: Melissa@applebutterdesign.com

Hand-lettered Name Cut-out Tags

Apple Butter Designs offers unique personalized gifts, like, our signature hand-lettering style by our owner, Melissa, in various keepsakes

Home Sweet Home

A favorite classic hymn can bring back so many memories. Let Melissa help curate in her personal hand-letting style a keepsake for your home in a timeless way.

Simply Blessed

A favorite classic hymn can bring back so many memories. Let Melissa help curate in her personal hand-letting style a keepsake for your home in a timeless way.

Blessed Assurance

A favorite classic hymn can bring back so many memories. Let Melissa help curate in her personal hand-letting style a keepsake for your home in a timeless way.

Shop by Category

Apparel & More

For the Office

Senior Year

Hymal Art

School Spirit

Custom Wood Signs

Questions? Contact us here

Home Fragrances

Wedding

Shop ALL Our Products

Subscribe Form

Frequently asked questions

Where are we located?

Do we have specific in-person shopping hours?

Can I return/exchange a product?

Do you guys make those LARGE nursery name signs?

Can I return or get a refund on my product

What payment methods do you accept?

​

Follow us on Instagram