top of page

we love custom orders reach out to us today

APPLE BUTTER DESIGNS

WHERE MEMORIES BECOME KEEPSAKES

Home
About Us
Hymnal Art
Graduation
Gift Card
Beyond The Barn
Events
Apparel & Accessories
Christmas
Graduation
Desk Accessories
Wedding
Original Artwork
Bookworm
Shop
Home Fragrances by Milkhouse Candle Co
School Spirit
More

Use tab to navigate through the menu items.

Looking for something:

Shop by Category

Apparel & More

Miss Pollen Pants Handy Tote

Miss Pollen Pants Scrunchy

Miss Pollen Pants Headband

Miss Pollen Pants Girls t-shirt

VIEW ALL

For the Office

Blushing Blooms Desk Mat

Miss Pollen Pants Desk Mat

CUSTOM Desk Nameplate

VIEW ALL

Senior Year

2026 DIY Graduation Cut-Out

Personalized Sports Signs

Wooden Card Keeper

2026 Grad CUSTOM Name Sign

VIEW ALL

Hymal Art

School Spirit

Best Teacher Gift Card Holder

Personalized Sports Jersey

School Spirit Shoelace Tags

2026 DIY Graduation Cut-Out

VIEW ALL

Custom Wood Signs

Springtime Blooms

Sending Love

Car Charms

Engraved Recipe Board

VIEW ALL

Questions? Contact us here

Name: Apple Butter Designs LLC
Address: 4432 East 750 North, Shelbyville, IN, 46176, US
Telephone: 317-395-3112

First name*

Last name

Email*

Write a message

Home Fragrances

Milkhouse Candle Co Waxmelts

Wedding

Personalized gift using personal handwriting

Gift using personal handwriting side view

Loved One's Own Handwriting Keepsake

Initial Engraved Bamboo Utensil Set

Recipe For Love

Wooden Card Keeper

VIEW ALL

Shop ALL Our Products

All
Apparel & Accessories
Car Charms
Desk Accessories
DIY Corner
Christmas
Graduation
Greeting Cards
Hymnal Art
Home Fragrances by Milkhouse Candle Co
Original Artwork
Ornaments/Gift Tags
School Spirit
Wedding
Wood Signs

$65

DIY Corner

2026 DIY Graduation Cut-Out
Price$10.50
Blushing Blooms Desk Mat
PriceFrom $13.50
Hand-Painted

Blushing Blooms
Price$22.00
Hi! I'm New Here

Personalized Birth Stats Baby Announcement
Price$16.70
Starting at $40

Engraved Recipe Board
PriceFrom $40.00
Blushing Bloom Women's PJ Top
PriceFrom $31.00
Loved One's Own Handwriting Keepsake
PriceFrom $65.00
Miss Pollen Pants Handy Tote
Price$22.00

Subscribe Form

Thanks for submitting!

Frequently asked questions

General

We're located in a cozy mini-barn in northern Shelby County, Indiana. Only about 2.5 miles south of Morristown. 4432 E 750 N, Shelbyville, IN 46176 You can find us on Google and Apple Maps.

Not really. lol We encourage everyone to message us a head of your requested visit for an appointment. We will have special holiday shopping hours though. And more info on that is located in our "Events" section.

Due to the nature of the majority of our items being personalized and custom pieces, no, we do not offer returns or exchanges. However, if we truly made an error on our part, we will do what is necessary to make that right.

We do offer our version of those actually. We offer free local pick-up for those types of large items. We do not offer shipping on this time though.

No. Due to the majority of our products being handcrafted and made specially for you, we do not offer refunds, returns, or exchanges. All sales are final. HOWEVER, if we truly made an error on our part, we will strive to correct the situation. We do all that we can to ensure you love your item(s) upon delivery and pick-up.

We accept credit cards, PayPal, Apple Pay, Google Pay, card reader, tap to pay, and, of course Cash when visiting us in-person.

Melissa@applebutterdesigns.com

Located in the mini-barn

Shelbyville, Indiana 46176 317-395-3112

Today is called a “bedroom takeover” .. it’s too chilly outside for me to finish these beauties up… soooo I brought them inside . lol have a fan in them to speed up the drying process so I can personalize them

Need a Mother’s Day gift? Reach out to me!

-Melissa

#raisedGarden #PersonalizedRaisedGarden #handPaintedGardenBox #appleButterDesigns #RuralIndiana

Boy! We’re just starting to get alllll kinds of critters added! Tomorrow, Mr. Mahin will be working on cutting out a horse!!

In order to have in time for local pick-up for Mother’s Day, please place (and pay) for your orders by tomorrow, Friday, April 24.

That is for all custom orders, even the raised cedar garden boxes too, if you’re wanting for the upcoming special holiday 🥰

To order, send me a PM. Remember these are local pick-up only due to size

*please note: flowers are NOT included …

Who said they wished we’d make CHICKEN flower boxes?!?
Like the cow, pig, horse, and tractor??

#chickenFlowerBox #customFlowerBox #appleButterDesigns #turningMemoriesIntoKeepsakes

Ok soooo I wanted to share a little behind the scenes with y’all!! Not only do we turn your memories into keepsakes, ummm, I grow my own herbs! Like, peppermint, LOTS of it! Why? Because I LOVE it in my teas and I just happened to run out of it last night. So what a better time to go harvest it for the first time of the season than this morning, in my PJs, and before brushing my hair, or putting on any kind of make-up! Herb harvesting is like a whole “natural vibe” y’all and well, I needed to get it done before I got distracted and busy with everyone’s orders. Which I LOVE to do too! Sooooo whatcha think? Do I need to add dried herbs to our store?

#freshHerbs #FreshMint #appleButterDesigns #earlyMorningHarvest #honeyBeesBuzzing

We love a good “thinking outside of the box” request! And Allie certainly had us doing that with her recent order. She loved our raised flower boxes…. Buuuut she wanted a cow. 🐄 .. and let’s personalize it! This was a team effort for Mr. Mahin and me. This one measures 36” wide by 26” tall ..
so yes!! Can we make a cow flower planter box??!? YES, yes we can!

To order yours, just send me a PM or comment here and I’ll floor-up with ya .

-Melissa

*Please note that all flower boxes orders are for local pick-up only. Shipping is not available for this item.

#cowFlowerbox #flowerBox #AppleButterDesigns #UniqueFlowerBox

One more step to go in the hand-painted Bibles. Then they will be ready for new homes 🥰🥰

These truly make wonderful gifts! Weddings, baptisms, birthdays, anniversaries, allll the holidays and just because too!

It’s almost time!! Time for graduation open houses and we can help!! Here are some example of personalized grad signs we’ve made. Starting this year, these got a little “upgrade” the 2026 will be “chunkier” so there’s room for guests to add their signatures annnd they’re BIGGER!
Personalize and order yours today!
https://www.applebutterdesigns.com/product-page/2024-grad-custom-name-sign

#2026Senior #graduationOpenHouses #personalizedGradSigns #appleButterDesigns

Ohhhh gosh I love how this personalized nursery sign turned out!! 🥰
Thank you Gabby for this honor and privilege of creating your keepsake for the newest addition to your family!! I hope big sis approves ;)

💜💜💜

#handpaintedNurseryDecor #PersonalizedNurseryDecor #appleButterDesigns #handPaintedFlorals #IndianaArtist

Some customer request are super fun and creative!! Where’s my cow peeps and what do you think we’re making????

We just kicked off “Raised Garden box season” with the beauty getting picked up last night! These are made of cedar built by Mr. Mahin and then I get to share my talents with personalizing each box front with original artwork!

Perfect keepsake for porches, patios and even smaller spaces like balconies!

Order yours today by reaching out to me!

*local pick-up only

#raisedGardenBed #personalizedGardenBox #appleButterDesigns

God is GOOD! No matter what the circumstances are in our lives, He will use it for good! Now through April 22 ALL hymnal art in our online store is 50% off! Yes, allllll the hymnal art.. use promo code GoodGod50 at checkout to receive the discount 🥰🙌🙏✝️

https://www.applebutterdesigns.com/hymnal-art

#hymnalArt #GodIsGood #OriginalArt #appleButterDesigns

We hope you had an amazing Easter. We pray that we all always remember Christ’s sacrifice for all of us.. ever . single. day!

Today is paint-it-up day.. working on a raised cedar garden box and a commissioned sign for a new baby girl!! (big sis has requested purple 🥰) next up with be a custom seamless pattern that includes: pizza , ice cream and hoagies!!

.pro-gallery-wix-wrapper {display: block !important;} .pro-gallery-wix-wrapper .gallery-item-container {opacity: 1 !important; display: block !important;}

Follow us on Instagram

@applebutter_designs

bottom of page

Looking for something:

Shop by Category

Apparel & More

For the Office

Senior Year

Hymal Art

School Spirit

Custom Wood Signs

Questions? Contact us here

Home Fragrances

Wedding

Shop ALL Our Products

Subscribe Form

Frequently asked questions

Where are we located?

Do we have specific in-person shopping hours?

Can I return/exchange a product?

Do you guys make those LARGE nursery name signs?

Can I return or get a refund on my product

What payment methods do you accept?

Follow us on Instagram

Shop by Category

Apparel & More

For the Office

Senior Year

Hymal Art

School Spirit

Custom Wood Signs

Questions? Contact us here

Home Fragrances

Wedding

Shop ALL Our Products

Subscribe Form

Frequently asked questions

Where are we located?

Do we have specific in-person shopping hours?

Can I return/exchange a product?

Do you guys make those LARGE nursery name signs?

Can I return or get a refund on my product

What payment methods do you accept?

​

Follow us on Instagram