top of page

We're so happy you're here!

we love custom orders reach out to us today

APPLE BUTTER DESIGNS

WHERE MEMORIES BECOME KEEPSAKES

Home
About Us
Wooden Signs
Hymnal Art
Gift Card
More

Use tab to navigate through the menu items.

All
Christmas
Hymnal Art
Bookmarks
Greeting Cards
Car Charms
Wood Signs
Knit Beanies
Graduation
Jewelry
Custom Desk Nameplate
School Spirit
Card Keeper
Wedding
Ornaments/Gift Tags
Milkhouse Candle Co

$0

$65

New Arrival

School Spirit Shoelace Tags
PriceFrom $8.00
Original Artwork

Springtime Blooms
PriceFrom $20.00
Handpainted

Sending Love
PriceFrom $15.00
Starting at $40

Engraved Recipe Board
PriceFrom $40.00
Milkhouse Candle Co Waxmelts
Price$9.75
Loved One's Own Handwriting Keepsake
PriceFrom $65.00
Recipe For Love
Price$30.00
New Arrival

Knit Beanies
Price$16.00
Personalize Me

Personalized Sports Jersey
Price$12.50
Personalized Sports Signs
Price$48.00
New Arrival

Everyone Needs A Little Jesus
Out of stock
Sweet Friendship
Regular Price$16.00Sale Price$12.00
ON SALE

Farmhouse Initial Engraved Ornament
Price$5.00
Hi! I'm New Here

Personalized Birth Stats Baby Announcement
Price$16.70
Personalized Name Wood Ornament
Price$10.00

Need a custom piece? Reach out to us here

Y’all!!! How cute are the shoes I painted with the gold mirror acrylic “Faith” shoelace tags?!?!? 😍😍😍😍

#goldMirror #shoelaces #customShoes #appleButterDesigns #handPaintedKicks

Y’all!!! How cute are the shoes I painted with the gold mirror acrylic “Faith” shoelace tags?!?!? 😍😍😍😍

#goldMirror #shoelaces #customShoes #appleButterDesigns #handPaintedKicks

Now available in our online store!! Starting at $8!! If you need help, just send me a text at 317-395-3112

AppleButterDesigns.com

#schoolSpirit #shoelaceTags #shoelaces #appleButterDesigns #madeInIndiana

Now available in our online store!! Starting at $8!! If you need help, just send me a text at 317-395-3112

AppleButterDesigns.com

#schoolSpirit #shoelaceTags #shoelaces #appleButterDesigns #madeInIndiana

School Spirit Shoelace tags now available in our online store! Starting at $10 .. personalize with soooo many options!
If you have any questions or need help ordering, reach out to me 🥰
AppleButterDesigns.com

#shoelaceSwag #schoolSpiritShoelaceTag #shoelaceCharms #appleButterDesigns #shoeCharms

School Spirit Shoelace tags now available in our online store! Starting at $10 .. personalize with soooo many options!
If you have any questions or need help ordering, reach out to me 🥰
AppleButterDesigns.com

#shoelaceSwag #schoolSpiritShoelaceTag #shoelaceCharms #appleButterDesigns #shoeCharms

Just one of many steps of the process to make those cute school spirit shoelace tags! Hang tight. I’ll get them added to our online store as soon as I can 🥰

Just one of many steps of the process to make those cute school spirit shoelace tags! Hang tight. I’ll get them added to our online store as soon as I can 🥰

Now through Sunday, February 8, our School Spirit Shoelace Tags are at an introductory price of $10/pair (must be an identical pair, like in photos)

Message me to order yours today. I don’t have these listed in the online store yet

On Monday, February 9th they will start at $13/pair ..

#applebutterdesigns #schoolSpirit #shoelaceTags #shoeSwag #shoeCharms

Now through Sunday, February 8, our School Spirit Shoelace Tags are at an introductory price of $10/pair (must be an identical pair, like in photos)

Message me to order yours today. I don’t have these listed in the online store yet

On Monday, February 9th they will start at $13/pair ..

#applebutterdesigns #schoolSpirit #shoelaceTags #shoeSwag #shoeCharms

Are you at the game this morning?? I’ve got ONE pair of JACKETS school spirit lace charms, a few pairs of earrings… annnnd I have earrings for Waldron and Triton (sorry, I’ve sold out of Southwestern, and you can always place an order 😉)

Snap a selfie with our digital banner when it pops us, post and tag us for goody in your inbox!

Let’s go JACKETS!
🖤💛🐝💛🖤

Are you at the game this morning?? I’ve got ONE pair of JACKETS school spirit lace charms, a few pairs of earrings… annnnd I have earrings for Waldron and Triton (sorry, I’ve sold out of Southwestern, and you can always place an order 😉)

Snap a selfie with our digital banner when it pops us, post and tag us for goody in your inbox!

Let’s go JACKETS!
🖤💛🐝💛🖤

Ummmm just sayin… whyyyyy did I wait so long to create these?!? Engraved and paint-filled, School Spirit Shoelace Tags!
Just in time for tomorrow’s 6th grade boys basketball county tourney! (And high school boys sectionals!)

And like just to wear in general!!

I don’t have them in the online store yet, because I literally just designed them a couple of hours ago!

Send me a PM order! I only have 3 pairs available for Jackets tomorrow ..

Ummmm just sayin… whyyyyy did I wait so long to create these?!? Engraved and paint-filled, School Spirit Shoelace Tags!
Just in time for tomorrow’s 6th grade boys basketball county tourney! (And high school boys sectionals!)

And like just to wear in general!!

I don’t have them in the online store yet, because I literally just designed them a couple of hours ago!

Send me a PM order! I only have 3 pairs available for Jackets tomorrow ..

Order of Love Day class goodies heading out today!! Aren’t these so fun?!? And that’s his own handwriting for his name.. what a special keepsake!

To order yours, message me today to have ready for local pick-up before class parties

Order of Love Day class goodies heading out today!! Aren’t these so fun?!? And that’s his own handwriting for his name.. what a special keepsake!

To order yours, message me today to have ready for local pick-up before class parties

Ok … like, as a small biz owner, I do love me a cute caricature…. Especially when it ties all my favorite parts of my job in a pretty pink bow! 🎀✝️ 🖼️ 🎨 ⚡️ 🪵

Ok … like, as a small biz owner, I do love me a cute caricature…. Especially when it ties all my favorite parts of my job in a pretty pink bow! 🎀✝️ 🖼️ 🎨 ⚡️ 🪵

There’s some requests that I truly need to hear the Holy Spirit to take me through a whole process in creating keepsakes that people entrusts for us to make…. This newest project was just that…. And I’m so thankful for the opportunity that God gives us to create special keepsakes for all of you!

#appleButterDesigns #whenACardinalAppears #illHaveANewLife #illHaveANewBody #repurposedhymns

There’s some requests that I truly need to hear the Holy Spirit to take me through a whole process in creating keepsakes that people entrusts for us to make…. This newest project was just that…. And I’m so thankful for the opportunity that God gives us to create special keepsakes for all of you!

#appleButterDesigns #whenACardinalAppears #illHaveANewLife #illHaveANewBody #repurposedhymns

Are you at the Yellowjackets game tonight?!? Take a pic of our digital banner, post AND TAG us for a treat

💛🖤🐝🖤💛

Are you at the Yellowjackets game tonight?!? Take a pic of our digital banner, post AND TAG us for a treat

💛🖤🐝🖤💛

Me… looking around for what to paint next…. Spies this cute brown plain brown tote in my bedroom… can y’all tell I’m ready for spring ?!?

#handPaintedHandbag #handPaintedPurse #canvasTote #floralsOnCanvas #floralToteBag #prettyCuteTote #prettyPurse #letsJazzItUp #appleButterDesigns

Me… looking around for what to paint next…. Spies this cute brown plain brown tote in my bedroom… can y’all tell I’m ready for spring ?!?

#handPaintedHandbag #handPaintedPurse #canvasTote #floralsOnCanvas #floralToteBag #prettyCuteTote #prettyPurse #letsJazzItUp #appleButterDesigns

.pro-gallery-wix-wrapper {display: block !important;} .pro-gallery-wix-wrapper .gallery-item-container {opacity: 1 !important; display: block !important;}

Follow us on Instagram

@applebutter_designs

Apple Butter Designs, LLC

Subscribe Form

Thanks for submitting!

Melissa@applebutterdesigns.com

Located in the mini-barn at 4432 E 750 N

Shelbyville, Indiana 46176 317-395-3112

Frequently asked questions

General

We're located in a cozy mini-barn in northern Shelby County, Indiana. Only about 2.5 miles south of Morristown. 4432 E 750 N, Shelbyville, IN 46176 You can find us on Google and Apple Maps.

Not really. lol We encourage everyone to message us a head of your requested visit for an appointment. We will have special holiday shopping hours though. And more info on that is located in our "Events" section.

Due to the nature of the majority of our items being personalized and custom pieces, no, we do not offer returns or exchanges. However, if we truly made an error on our part, we will do what is necessary to make that right.

We do offer our version of those actually. We offer free local pick-up for those types of large items. We do not offer shipping on this time though.

No. Due to the majority of our products being handcrafted and made specially for you, we do not offer refunds, returns, or exchanges. All sales are final. HOWEVER, if we truly made an error on our part, we will strive to correct the situation. We do all that we can to ensure you love your item(s) upon delivery and pick-up.

We accept credit cards, PayPal, Apple Pay, Google Pay, card reader, tap to pay, and, of course Cash when visiting us in-person.

©2026 Apple Butter Designs. All rights reserved.

bottom of page